Bluffton University
OH
DIII
Heartland Collegiate
DIII men's programs in the same state as Bluffton University.
| School | City | Conference |
|---|---|---|
| Defiance | Defiance | Heartland Collegiate |
| Mount St. Joseph | Cincinnati | Heartland Collegiate |
| Baldwin Wallace | Berea | Ohio Athletic |
| Capital | Columbus | Ohio Athletic |
| Case Western Reserve | Cleveland | University Athletic Association |
| Denison | Granville | North Coast |
| Franciscan University of Steubenville | — | Allegheny Mountain |
| Heidelberg | Tiffin | Ohio Athletic |
| Hiram | Hiram | North Coast |
| John Carroll | University Heights | Ohio Athletic |
| Kenyon | Gambier | North Coast |
| Marietta | Marietta | Ohio Athletic |
| Mount Union | Alliance | Ohio Athletic |
| Muskingum | New Concord | Ohio Athletic |
| Oberlin | Oberlin | North Coast |
| Ohio Northern | Ada | Ohio Athletic |
| Ohio Wesleyan | Delaware | North Coast |
| Otterbein | Westerville | Ohio Athletic |
| Wilmington (Ohio) | wilmington | Ohio Athletic |
| Wittenberg | Springfield | North Coast |
| Wooster | Wooster | North Coast |
